Pro Bono Service Critical in Acquisition of The Advocacy Center’s New Building
Charlotte Center for Legal Advocacy has purposefully been searching for a new building for over two years to accommodate our growing staff and programs. Jane Ratteree of Robinson Bradshaw & Hinson represented The Advocacy Center in a real estate transaction in which we acquired the building that will be our new home beginning later this year. Ratteree’s service and expertise were invaluable to The Advocacy Center as we navigated this search and transaction process. Because of Ratteree, our future modern office space will represent the respect and esteem that The Advocacy Center’s staff and clients deserve.
The building’s transaction was complex. The seller was an international organization with its headquarters in Florida and officers in Puerto Rico. In order to make the properties function as a coherent campus once legally separated, Ratteree negotiated and executed a reciprocal easement agreement with multiple provisions. The property also included an access easement on adjoining land that needed to be preserved for both properties.
Ratteree contributed over 200 hours of her time to this effort. Ratteree’s work will facilitate the creation of The Advocacy Center’s future home that will enable it to better serve the community for years to come.
Ratteree’s commitment to serving low-income families in North Carolina through these complex projects demonstrates the her innovative and comprehensive approach to pro bono service. She went above and beyond to ensure the Charlotte-Mecklenburg community has equal access to justice and civil legal aid. We applaud her creative leadership of non-traditional pro bono initiatives and hope that Ratteree and efforts inspire others.
The Mecklenburg Access to Justice Pro Bono Partners Program of Charlotte Center for Legal Advocacy and Legal Aid of North Carolina-Charlotte is pleased to recognize our committed pro bono attorneys who donated at least 20 hours of service or closed three or more cases for our clients in 2020.
Individuals with asterisks next to their names completed more than 50 hours of pro bono service in 2020.
Congratulations and thank you to the dedicated legal professionals listed below. Each of you has played a key role in helping our agencies provide access to justice to low-income clients in our community.
Stephen D. Allred
*Keith F. Atkinson
Katharine Yale Barnes
Robert Locke Beatty
Russel P. Blaise*
Linda Elise Boss
Demi Lorant Bostian*
Richard Christian Brose
Hugh Hagan Brown
Emily Lynn Cantrell
Jules Wesley Carter*
Diana C. Castro*
Avery Devin Catlin
Joy McMurry Chappell
Katherine Susie Clarke
Amanda Marie Colley
David A. Concha*
Richar H. Conner III*
G. Lee Cory Jr.*
Carly Michelle Couch*
Matthew H. Crow*
Heather W. Culp*
Kevin L. Denny
Adam Karl Doerr*
W. Scott Dove
Addison Walker Dufour
Anastasia Elizabeth Fanning
Richard L. Farley
Walter D. Fisher Jr.*
Jacob Richard Franchek*
Jasmine Kelly Gardner
Edward Staples Garrett*
Matille Clark Gibbons
Christ K. Glista*
Jeffre C. Grady*
Stephanie E. Greer Fulcher
George V. Hanna III
James T. Hedrick Jr.
William Robinson Heroy*
Karen Marie Hinkley*
Travis Styres Hinman
Thomas G. Hooper
Rebecca Joan Horton
Brett Alan Hubler
Alexis Marie Iffert
David H. Jones
Sarah B. Kemble
Mark W. Kinghorn*
Heryka Rodriguez Knoespel*
Jonathan C. Krisko
Jodie H. Lawson*
Emily H. Leazer
Nicholas Haynes Lee
Antone J. Little*
Lauren Elizabeth Lowry
Dana C. Lumsden
Jonathan Adam Martin
Hilary Renee Levine May
William C. Mayberry
Lauren Nicole McHale*
Thomas E. McNeill*
Emma Claire Merritt
Samuel Clinton Merritt*
Elizabeth C. Murphy
Sara Elizabeth Ohlman
Fern A. Paterson
Kim Brett Perez
Kathleen Elizabeth Perkins
Benjam M. Petitto*
Benjamin Scott Pleune
Claire J. Rauscher
Marla Tun Reschly
Etheridge Brittin Ricks*
Carlo L. Rodes
Robert J. Roth*
Brian Michael Rowlson
Lee Kimball Royster
Brett Michael Shockley
Ronald J. Shook
Courtney Crook Shytle
John N. Suhr Jr.
Nadira Aisha Swinton
Daniel Lee Tedrick*
Nicholas Evan Tosco
Leslie Campbell Tucker III
Ann Lee Warren
R. Kent Warren
Sara Page Waugh
Brian Marlowe Weynand
Abigail Forrister Williams
Joseph Miles Wobbleton
Fred M. Wood Jr.
Karlee Nicole Wroblewski
Julian H. Wright Jr.*
Erik R. Zimmerman*
North Carolina attorney volunteers!
Be sure to report your pro bono hours to the N.C. Pro Bono Resource Center to be recognized with your colleagues statewide for your service. Visit ncprobono.org/volunteer/ to learn more about the N.C. Rule of Professional Conduct 6.1 and statewide pro bono initiatives.
Attorneys who report at least 50 hours of pro bono legal services in a year will be inducted into the NC Pro Bono Honor Society and receive a certificate from the Supreme Court of North Carolina recognizing their service. Learn more and report your hours at https://ncprobono.org/report/.
Justice for Lake Arbor Tenants Subjected to Dangerous Housing Conditions
The NC Justice Center, Charlotte Center for Legal Advocacy, and the law firm of Robinson Bradshaw filed a lawsuit in 2019 against the former owners and property managers on behalf of class of Lake Arbor tenants who had paid rent during periods of time when serious Housing Code violations were left unrepaired in their units.
To read the Lake Arbor settlement agreement click here.
If you believe you are entitled to funds from the Lake Arbor settlement, please fill out this online form (English) (Spanish) or leave a voicemail at 704 376-1600 ext. 524.
Si usted piensa que tiene derecho a recibir fondos del avenimiento de Lake Arbor, por favor llene este formulario en línea (inglés)(español).
Charlotte (Dec. 9, 2020) – The former owners and managers of west Charlotte’s Lake Arbor Apartments agreed to pay $547,500, to settle litigation brought on behalf of a class of former tenants. The Charlotte Housing Inspector found the class of former tenants’ apartments to have dangerous conditions.
The North Carolina Justice Center, Charlotte Center for Legal Advocacy, and Robinson Bradshaw represented plaintiffs in the case against Lake Arbor Dean TIC LLC and Lake Arbor 80M TIC, LLC, as well as former property managers Broad Management Group, LLC and Wellington Advisors, LLC. The state Superior Court complaint alleged that the former Lake Arbor owners and property managers violated Charlotte’s Housing Code and North Carolina consumer protection laws between 2015 and 2019 when they improperly sought and collected rent from tenants living in Lake Arbor apartments found to have dangerous conditions. The complaint alleged that the Lake Arbor Apartments owners’ and property managers’ actions violated North Carolina’s Unfair and Deceptive Trade Practices Act, Unfair Debt Collections Act, and Residential Rental Agreements Act. The defendants denied those allegations and claimed that they did nothing wrong or illegal.
“These landlords kept taking the rent and taking the rent, all the while refusing to fix serious safety problems in tenants’ units, as found by the City,” said former Lake Arbor tenant and class plaintiff Serita Russell. “It’s about time they were called to account. I’m glad the lawsuit was settled, and I hope other landlords take this as a lesson on what happens when a landlord cares more about making money than the safety of its tenants.”
After the filing, Lake Arbor evicted all tenants rather than complete repairs. The defendants then sold the property to New York-based URS Capital Partners in April. This sequence of events exposed how dire Charlotte’s affordable housing crisis has become, leaving tenants vulnerable to displacement and homelessness just for exercising their rights to a safe and habitable place to live.
An important consequence of the litigation is that landlords in Charlotte will think twice about allowing dangerous conditions to persist at their properties.
“Landlords and property managers are legally obligated to keep units in a fit and habitable condition and make timely repairs of all violations noted by local housing inspectors,” said Julian Wright, an attorney at Robinson Bradshaw. “Continuing to collect rent while failing to make such repairs can itself violate the law, subjecting the landlords to the possibility of treble damages and attorneys’ fees.”
The North Carolina Justice Center is one of the state’s preeminent voices for economic and social justice. As a leading progressive research and advocacy organization, its mission is to eliminate poverty in North Carolina by ensuring that every household in the state has access to the resources, services, and fair treatment it needs to achieve economic security. For more information, visit www.ncjustice.org
Charlotte Center for Legal Advocacy (formerly Legal Services of Southern Piedmont) provides expert legal advice and representation to those who cannot afford it, but desperately need it, something the organization has been doing since its inception in 1967. The Advocacy Center serves more than 3,500 families each year who are facing a crisis of safety, shelter, health or income. Charlotte Center for Legal Advocacy provides committed advocacy work on behalf of clients, resulting in policy changes at the local and national level to impact a greater number of people. Charlotte Center for Legal Advocacy is a champion for those in need, ensuring their safety, economic security and family stability. For more information, visit charlottelegaladvocacy.org.
Robinson Bradshaw is a Carolinas-based corporate law firm celebrating 60 years of providing comprehensive legal services to our clients. We represent businesses across the country ranging from startups to Fortune 100 companies. Visit robinsonbradshaw.com for more information
Celebrate Pro Bono Week October 25th-31st, 2020
We have to shout it from the rooftops. Our Access to Justice Pro Bono Partners Program enables Charlotte Center for Legal Advocacy and Legal Aid of North Carolina–Charlotte to have an immense impact on our society, narrow Mecklenburg County’s justice gap, and to build a stronger, more just community for us all.
Locally and Nationally Recognized Volunteers and Programs
We recognized nearly 100 volunteer attorneys who donated at least 20 hours of service in the last year. From executing wills to helping immigrant children, these attorneys are dedicated to access to justice in Charlotte-Mecklenburg and beyond.
Of these attorneys, several were recognized for their commitment to pro bono by the Mecklenburg Bar. Blas P. Arroyo, senior counsel at Alston & Bird LLP, and Emma Merritt, attorney with Hunton Andrews and Kurth LLP, received this accolade for their respective work on criminal record expunctions and medicaid advocacy with Charlotte Center for Legal Advocacy. Paul Kinny, a long term attorney with Duke Energy, spent ten weeks assisting Legal Aid of NC–Charlotte with housing cases. Moore & Van Allen PLLC received the firm award for their dedication of over 300 hours of representation in landlord-tenant cases. Learn more about those recognized here.
Finally, the Charlotte Triage Pro Bono Partnership received two awards from the North Carolina Bar Association and the Pro Bono Institute this year for its innovative approach to engaging local attorneys with and training them in six of the most pressing legal issues affecting Mecklenburg County: human trafficking, housing, social security benefits, driver’s license restoration, criminal record expunctions, and affordable healthcare. This year we trained over 200 attorneys and advocates to volunteer with our programs through the Charlotte Triage Pro Bono Partnership.
Meet Heryka Knoespel and Elizabeth Murphy: Learn their “Why”
Katten Attorney Joins Advocacy Center to Support Community Redevelopment
Katten Muchin Roseman LLP has allowed one of its attorneys to join the Charlotte Center for Legal Advocacy’s staff this summer to support efforts to provide stability for families in the Charlotte metro region.
Max Swindle joined Charlotte Center for Legal Advocacy May 26, as part of a three-month attorney loan program. Swindle, a real estate attorney specializing in commercial real estate finance, is working with the Advocacy Center’s Consumer Protection Program to help people clean up their criminal records and get drivers licenses restored.
For the more than 2 million North Carolinians with a criminal record, finding jobs, housing and opportunity is an uphill battle. And one in seven N.C. adults has a suspended drivers license, leaving them unable to effectively get to work, school or run everyday errands without a car.
These issues disproportionately impact people based on income and race, which is why the Advocacy Center’s Community Redevelopment Project seeks to eliminate these barriers to opportunity and promote equity in our community.
“I am so excited to have Max join us to do this important work,” said attorney Lashieka Hardin, who manages the Community Redevelopment Project. “I look forward to seeing all the great things we do together as team over the next few months.”
Adding a full-time attorney to focus on these two practice areas is an innovative approach that enables the Advocacy Center to serve more people in need, provide stability and promote economic opportunity.
Center for Legal Advocacy’s Diana Godoy interviewed Swindle during his first
week on the job. Learn a bit more about him in his own words:
About Max Swindle …
“I grew up in North Carolina, went to UNC-Chapel Hill for undergrad and then stayed there for law school. I graduated law school in 2017, and I moved out to Denver, Colorado to work. I was there until December 2018. And then my wife , who I met in law school, and I moved back to North Carolina. She’s originally from Charlotte. I’m from Winston-Salem. So, we just decided to move home.”
What he does at Katten Muchin Rosenman LLP …
graduating law school, I have been working as an attorney for Katten Muchin
Rosenman and their real estate finance practice group. I represent lenders,
different commercial banks and investment groups and originating new loans for
the commercial mortgage backed securities market.”
Why he came to Charlotte Center for Legal Advocacy …
“With the COVID-19 outbreak, my practice area has been very slow the last few months, really ever since March. Our office managing partner and our deputy general counsel had been in contact with Charlotte Center for Legal Advocacy to see if they could use some help over the next few months with the expunction and driver’s license restoration programs.
They asked me if [joining the Advocacy Center staff] was something I was interested in. And I said, ‘Yeah, that’ll be great.’ I just hope I can pitch in and pick up on these new areas of practice as quickly as I can to be of use.”
What he will be doing …
“For this first week, I’ve been working on a few cases in-house with Lashieka Hardin to kind of get my feet on the ground, kind of understanding how this all works.
And then I believe starting next week, I’m going to start helping with a new driver’s license restoration project. We look at clients that have already been in contact with Charlotte Center for Legal Advocacy, and they have either some misdemeanor or felony charges on their record that could be eligible to be removed if they meet certain criteria. We review those, figure out what we can do, and we file petitions with the different [N.C.] counties where those charges show up.
We hope to get these charges off people’s records because having different charges listed can hinder people getting housing, getting jobs, getting loans, things like that. And I think that’ll continue throughout the summer. I think some of it will be helping coordinate clinics and with outside pro bono attorneys, kind of helping them handle different client interactions.”
What he’s looking forward to …
“Just getting to interact with a great group of attorneys who are very, very good at what they do. I’ve been a part of the few video meetings this first week with the Consumer Protection group. Everyone’s super nice, super passionate about what they’re doing. The work is great: helping people with complex problems that that can really affect your everyday life.
It’s about just getting to work with such great people and give back to the community. I don’t have as much time as I would like to do this work in my normal firm job, so this has been a great opportunity.”
What he hopes to get out of this experience …
“I’m going to try and just absorb as much information as I can so that hopefully when these few months are over, I’ll be able to maybe come back to Charlotte Center for Legal Advocacy as a pro bono attorney to help out with things like expunctions or maybe this driver’s license restoration project later on. I would like to stay involved. I’m just hoping to learn as much as I can so that I can continue to be necessary.”
Thank you to Katten for partnering with Charlotte Center for Legal Advocacy in our mission to pursue justice for those in need. We are glad to have Max on our team!
Meck Bar Recognizes Access to Justice Pro Bono Attorneys
The Access to Justice Pro Bono Partners Program is proud to recognize its 2020 recipients of the Mecklenburg County Bar’s pro bono awards.
The Mecklenburg County Bar recognized these committed
individuals May 21, during its Annual Meeting, which was held virtually this
year due to the COVID-19 pandemic.
These attorneys and advocates enable us to serve more people in need, to narrow Mecklenburg County’s justice gap, and to build a stronger, more just community for us all.
This year’s recipients include attorneys, advocates and firms supporting Charlotte Center for Legal Advocacy and Legal Aid of North Carolina through their joint pro bono program, as well as Council for Children’s Rights and the Mecklenburg County Bar.
Charlotte Center for Legal Advocacy
Blas P. Arroyo is a skilled
advocate and outstanding mentor who is generous with his time and considerable
expertise. As a part of his Senior Counsel status at Alston & Bird LLP, Arroyo
has dedicated several hours each week to work with Charlotte Center for Legal
Advocacy clients as part of the Consumer Protection Program.
He has invested countless hours into Charlotte
Center for Legal Advocacy’s criminal records expunctions work, including
reviewing records for hundreds of clients and serving as an expert at dozens of
expunctions clinics since joining the organization in 2017.
In addition to helping with existing programs,
Arroyo also connected Charlotte Center for Legal Advocacy and The Relatives and
launched a partnership to help the teen and young-adult clients of The
Relatives receive advice and representation on expunctions. He has also helped
litigate several consumer-protection cases. Arroyo is always willing to take
the extra time to mentor and share his advice and wisdom. He is incredibly
talented and compassionate and has made a deep impact on the programs and
clients at Charlotte Center for Legal Advocacy.
Emma C. Merritt has been a pro bono volunteer with Charlotte Center for
Legal Advocacy since 2017, when she began serving clients with Medicaid and
Social Security denials through the Medicaid Appeals Project at her firm, Hunton
Andrews Kurth LLP. She has secured over $200,000 in benefits on behalf of
clients through these cases.
continuing these cases, Merritt added a major pro bono activity to her plate in
2018 when she joined Charlotte Center for Legal Advocacy’s Health Insurance
Navigator Project as a healthcare “champion” leading volunteer efforts to
support health insurance enrollment for Advocacy Center clients as part of the
Charlotte Triage Pro Bono Partnership.
consistently approaches her role with enthusiasm and is always willing to give
her time and resources. During her first year with the Navigator Project, Merritt
was there to enroll clients in coverage all day on the last day of the 2018
Affordable Care Act Open Enrollment period—a day that is often long and busy
for navigators. During the most recent open enrollment, Merritt helped with
consumer appointments, check-ins at enrollment events, and enlisted her
assistant to compile 1,000 healthcare information packets for consumers. We at Charlotte
Center for Legal Advocacy and our health access clients are fortunate to have Merritt
on our team!
Legal Aid of North Carolina-Charlotte
After a long
career as a lawyer with Duke Energy, Paul R. Kinny spent 10 weeks volunteering
with Legal Aid during his time off from his teaching position with Queens
University last summer. Although he is not licensed in North Carolina,
Paul helped where he could on housing cases in numerous ways:
interviewing clients, negotiating with landlords, conducting research, and
drafting pleadings and discovery. Kinny has now been approved by the N.C.
State Bar to represent clients in court and plans to continue his volunteer work
with Legal Aid. His dedication has resulted in better outcomes for many
clients and eased the burden on Legal Aid’s housing attorneys.
Legal Aid is proud to recognize Moore & Van Allen, PLLC as this year’s recipient of the firm award for its work supporting access to housing. Last year, 10 attorneys from Moore Van Allen volunteered to take on housing cases to protect tenants’ rights to decent housing. Those attorneys spent a total of more than 300 hours working for those clients. In addition, one of these volunteers continued to serve clients as one of three housing “champions” with the Charlotte Triage Pro Bono Partnership and placed dozens of housing cases with other pro bono attorneys at other firms in that role.
Council for Children’s Rights
Mandy Schuller was an obvious choice for this year’s
pro bono award, as she is the epitome of a champion for Council for Children’s
Rights. Schuller has been volunteering with CFCR in its Custody Advocacy
Program for over 6 years, where she serves as a best interest attorney for
children caught in the middle of high-conflict custody cases. In that time, she
has successfully represented 14 children across 6 challenging, time-intensive
always gone above and beyond as a volunteer for our child-clients. If we have a
difficult case that needs an experienced, dedicated, and passionate volunteer,
we know we can always turn to her. For the last 3 years, Schuller, a member of
Wells Fargo’s Legal Department, has been our point-person for the pro bono
partnership between Wells Fargo and CFCR. She recruits and encourages talented
Wells Fargo employees to volunteer with CFCR, and she is our liaison for
matching up volunteers with children in need. We are so grateful to Mandy and
all she does for CFCR, and we are so impressed that she does it all while being
a busy lawyer and mom!
We are excited to
announce Randi Guinn-Shirley as the recipient of this year’s pro bono award.
Her passion to serve children and young adults is undeniable. Prior to
relocating to Charlotte, she worked in New York representing children in
matters involving custody and visitation, child protection, and juvenile
delinquency to ensure their interests were protected and wishes expressed to
the court. In January 2008, Guinn-Shirley and her family moved to Charlotte,
and at that time she turned her focus on raising her children, one with special
needs, and caring for her family.
When Guinn-Shirley reached out to
Council for Children’s Rights about her interest in volunteering with the
Special Education Advocacy for Kids (SpEAK) Volunteer Program, she seemed like
a natural fit. She completely understood the need for students in foster care
to have someone able and willing to make special education decisions on their
behalf, especially for students who do not have anyone naturally involved in
their life able to serve that role.
In May 2019, she was among the third
group of volunteers to go through the SpEAK Volunteer Program training. Shortly
thereafter, Guinn-Shirley was appointed to serve as the Special Education
Decision Maker for a sibling group of seven, ranging from first grade to sixth
grade. During this school year, she has dedicated countless hours (over 150!)
to advocating for appropriate educational services for these seven students.
She has become intimately involved, getting to know their schools, their
teachers, their foster parents, their therapists, and most importantly these
students. They have greatly benefited from her enthusiasm, commitment, and
consistency. We are so grateful to Randi for her dedication and passion to this
Mecklenburg County Bar
Fitz Barringer is a partner at Robinson Bradshaw, where he plays an active role in promoting pro bono work within the firm. In addition to coordinating a summer associate pro bono project in partnership with Charlotte Center for Legal Advocacy, Barringer also volunteers with Legal Aid of North Carolina on landlord-tenant matters. His commitment to helping to serve the under served goes beyond the courtroom. Barringer also volunteers his time advising the board of a preschool situated in a low-income area of Charlotte that offers tuition-free care and education. In 2019 alone, Fitz reported 175 hours of pro bono work. The Mecklenburg County Bar thanks you for setting the example and for your leadership in the community!
Lynna Moen of Moen Legal Counsel began her pro bono journey with Safe Alliance while still in law school. She later became a Safe Alliance fellow and to this day continues to volunteer for Safe Alliance, representing domestic violence survivors. She also volunteers with Moore & Van Allen’s Human Trafficking Project through the Charlotte Triage Pro Bono Project, the Mecklenburg County Clerk’s Servicemembers Civil Relief Act, and the U.S. State Department’s Child Abduction Project. The Bar’s Pro Bono & Legal Recruitment Committee received an outpouring of heartfelt support for this nomination from both fellow Bar members and the leaders of the organizations with whom she volunteers. Congratulations, Lynna. The Bar and the community are lucky to have you in our midst!
Congratulations to the 2020 recipients of the Mecklenburg County Bar Pro Bono Awards!